Scottsdale Old Town vs Arcadia
Compare these two popular Phoenix neighborhoods side-by-side.Arcadia is more affordable with 2BR rents at $1,900/mo.
Scottsdale Old Town
Upscale, resort-style, touristy
2BR Rent$2,100/mo
68
Walk
42
Transit
65
Bike
Arcadia
MORE AFFORDABLEUpscale, resort-style, family-friendly
2BR Rent$1,900/mo
52
Walk
38
Transit
60
Bike
Rent Price Comparison
Monthly rent by bedroom type
| Unit Type | Scottsdale Old Town | Arcadia | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $1,200 | $1,100 | +$100(+9.1%) |
| 1 Bedroom | $1,500 | $1,400 | +$100(+7.1%) |
| 2 Bedroom | $2,100 | $1,900 | +$200(+10.5%) |
| 3 Bedroom | $3,000 | $2,700 | +$300(+11.1%) |
Which Neighborhood Wins?
affordability
Arcadia
Average rent is $133/mo higher
transit
Scottsdale Old Town
Transit score: 42 vs 38
walkability
Scottsdale Old Town
Walk score: 68 vs 52
nightlife
Scottsdale Old Town
Very active
families
Tie
Both neighborhoods are suitable for families
young Professionals
Tie
Both attract young professionals
commute
Arcadia
15-20 min to downtown
Scottsdale Old Town Overview
Upscale downtown Scottsdale with art galleries, fine dining, nightlife, and Southwest character.
Best For
Affluent residentsRetireesNightlife seekersResort lifestyle
Pros
- +Upscale amenities
- +Safe
- +Great dining
- +Entertainment
Cons
- -Expensive
- -Touristy
- -Car-dependent
- -Hot summers
Safety
Excellent
Commute
25-35 min
Nightlife
Very active - clubs, bars, entertainment
Schools
Excellent public schools
Arcadia Overview
Upscale neighborhood with Camelback Mountain views, excellent restaurants, boutique shopping, and resort-style living.
Best For
Affluent familiesOutdoor enthusiastsSchool quality seekersResort lifestyle
Pros
- +Beautiful setting
- +Great schools
- +Hiking access
- +Safe
Cons
- -Expensive
- -Car-dependent
- -Hot summers
- -Tourist-heavy
Safety
Excellent
Commute
15-20 min
Nightlife
Moderate - upscale bars, resort lounges
Schools
Top-rated public schools
Key Takeaways: Scottsdale Old Town vs Arcadia
- Affordability: Arcadia offers lower rents with 2BR averaging $1,900/mo compared to $2,100/mo.
- Walkability: Scottsdale Old Town has the edge with a Walk Score of 68.
- Transit: Scottsdale Old Town offers better public transit access (Transit Score: 42).
- Commute: Scottsdale Old Town (25-35 min) vsArcadia (15-20 min) to downtown.
Which Neighborhood is Right for You?
Scottsdale Old Town is ideal for affluent residents and retirees, offering upscale, resort-style, touristy vibes. Arcadia suits affluent families and outdoor enthusiasts, known for its upscale, resort-style, family-friendly atmosphere.